If anyone’s been interested in Dragon Quest XI, they’ve likely at least given it a shot by now. Thanks to its numerous ports, nearly everyone can play it these days, and its reputation as one of the premier modern RPGs isn’t exactly news either.
So, its Switch 2 port doesn’t mean much for existing owners. Its upgrades over the original Switch release are negligible, and the lack of an upgrade path is pretty awful. However, since we’ve somehow never reviewed Dragon Quest XI in any form, I figured this latest re-release was a good opportunity to finally give it that review.
I have a fairly extensive history with Dragon Quest XI. I 100-percented its original PS4 release, the enhanced XI S version on Switch, and then that same version again on PS4. So, you could say I know the game pretty well after roughly 400 hours. Despite all that time, though, I still hadn’t properly experienced an entire side of the game: its 2D mode.
For those unaware, Dragon Quest XI S introduced numerous changes and additions compared to its original PS4 counterpart, including an option that recreates the entire game in 2D. I’d never played the game this way before, so I figured it was finally time to try it for this review. And while I undeniably prefer the 3D format, it’s no exaggeration to say that playing in 2D makes Dragon Quest XI feel like a surprisingly different RPG.
2D mode is only one part of what XI S added, though. The enhanced release also added fully orchestrated music, Japanese voice acting, additional character-focused story chapters, faster battle speeds, a series of throwback scenarios to older games inspired by the area of Tickington, and numerous quality-of-life improvements. Having played both versions multiple times, I find it hard to imagine going back to the original release now.
Dragon Quest XI S Still Tells a Great RPG Story
Dragon Quest XI follows the Luminary, a silent protagonist who leaves his humble home village of Cobblestone to fulfill his destiny as the chosen one. It’s about as traditional an RPG premise as you can imagine. Dragon Quest has never been shy about embracing the genre’s foundations, and XI shows why that confidence can work so well.
The story is very much a slow burn. You’ll arrive at a new town, meet its residents, discover whatever problem is plaguing the area, and usually spend a few hours resolving it before continuing the larger journey. The series has always had this almost vignette-like structure, giving individual locations room for their own characters, conflicts, and stories.
At first, the overarching narrative can feel secondary to these smaller tales. Some can even seem largely disconnected from the purpose of the Luminary’s journey, but they make Erdrea feel considerably more lived-in. By taking its time, Dragon Quest XI gives you a chance to become familiar with its places and people instead of treating every location as another checkpoint between major plot developments.
That patience becomes increasingly integral, too. The Luminary’s adventure gets off to a bad start almost immediately, and later developments drastically expand what initially seems like a straightforward heroic journey. Without spoilers, Dragon Quest XI becomes far more ambitious than its opening hours suggest. Even after four playthroughs, I’m still impressed by how effectively it can return to familiar places, characters, and ideas under entirely different circumstances. The smaller stories that can initially seem like detours gradually become part of a world you’ve built an actual history with.
Playing in 2D made me appreciate that structure differently. Its quicker traversal lets you move through individual locations and their stories much faster, making the vignette-like nature of the adventure even more apparent. At the same time, losing the scale and detail of the 3D environments makes some of those places feel less substantial to me.
The party is an enormous part of why everything works as well as it does. Erik, Veronica, Serena, Sylvando, Jade, Rab, and the rest of the cast are certainly likable individually, but what has stuck with me across four playthroughs is how much time Dragon Quest XI gives them to become more. Their relationships and individual struggles undergo major developments, often building on personality traits and connections established much earlier.
XI S also adds character-focused scenarios that weren’t in the original release, giving several party members time in the spotlight away from the Luminary. They add context at a crucial point in the story while establishing that these characters have enough personality and history to remain compelling even when the Luminary isn’t the center of their lives.
That patience is one reason Dragon Quest XI’s enormous length works narratively for me. Mechanically, however, that same length exposes one of my biggest issues.
Turn-Based Combat and Draconian Quest Difficulty
Simplicity is at the core of Dragon Quest progression, and I rarely have an issue with that. Combat is familiar turn-based encounters with four active party members, and each character has enough individual mechanics and specialties to make party composition matter. Characters have their own skill panels that branch into different specialties, letting you invest in weapon types, passive bonuses, or character-specific abilities. Respeccing also gives you room to experiment without feeling permanently punished for a perceived wrong choice.
Buffs and debuffs remain genuinely useful, while the Pep system can temporarily strengthen characters and let you access Pep Powers when certain party members are pepped up together. These team abilities range from straightforward attacks to more specialized effects, and the flexibility of different builds and party compositions gives Dragon Quest XI more mechanical depth than its traditional appearance suggests.
The problem is that Dragon Quest XI doesn’t always require you to explore that depth. This is an enormous game even if you focus primarily on the main story, and the same mechanical simplicity that makes combat so immediately approachable can wear thin in the later hours. Once you establish reliable strategies and party roles, regular encounters can become routine, and the standard difficulty rarely applies enough pressure to make experienced RPG players reconsider what they’re doing.
I noticed that repetition even more during this playthrough because 2D mode fundamentally changes my relationship with regular battles. In 3D, enemies physically roam the environment, so after hundreds of hours, I can ignore encounters I have no interest in fighting. 2D mode returns to random encounters, meaning battles become unavoidable. That makes exploration feel more traditionally Dragon Quest, but it can also expose the repetition of regular combat more readily when you’ve already spent hundreds of hours mastering its systems. The encounter rate is also incredibly high.
Thankfully, Draconian Quest settings provide an answer for anyone wanting the combat to demand more from them. Stronger Monsters is the most obvious example, significantly increasing the pressure placed on equipment, buffs, debuffs, healing, and party composition. Other settings can restrict shopping, discourage grinding weaker enemies, or introduce stranger conditions such as Shypox. I find some of them needlessly gimmicky, but the more transformative options show that the underlying combat has enough depth to support much more resistance.
Crafting matters more when you can’t simply buy whatever equipment you want, while buffs and debuffs become increasingly valuable when bosses can genuinely punish poor decisions. Character builds similarly require more thought when brute force isn’t always enough. I still think the normal experience could stand to demand a little more from the player given its length, but I appreciate having the option to push these systems further.
How Dragon Quest XI’s 2D Mode Changes Exploration
The grandest change during this playthrough, though, was simply navigating the world in 2D. Towns, fields, and dungeons are completely recreated as overhead maps, while exploration and combat adopt conventions much closer to classic Dragon Quest.
The environments themselves feel dramatically different. Large 3D spaces become much more condensed overhead maps, so getting around is generally quicker. Dungeons retain their basic identities and purposes, but their layouts and navigation can feel wildly different when presented like a classic 16-bit RPG.
No single difference completely reinvents Dragon Quest XI, but together they noticeably alter the game’s cadence. The 3D version encourages me to linger in its environments and selectively engage enemies, whereas 2D mode creates a notable contradiction. Traversal itself is generally faster because environments are smaller and more condensed, yet random encounters interrupt that movement far more frequently. You can get from one side of a town or field to the other faster, but you have less control over what happens along the way.
Neither approach is inherently better, but they emphasize different strengths. The 2D format brings XI considerably closer to the older games it draws so much inspiration from, while the condensed geography inevitably makes Erdrea feel smaller. A journey that can seem genuinely expansive in 3D becomes more abstract when entire regions are represented through comparatively compact maps.
Dragon Quest XI’s 2D and 3D Presentation Compared
The audiovisual differences are similarly substantial. Dragon Quest XI’s 3D format benefits enormously from seeing Akira Toriyama’s distinct character and monster designs realized through expressive models and animation. Erdrea is bright and colorful, and its towns and regions have immediately identifiable personalities. The cinematic framing also gives major story moments a scale the 2D interpretation can’t naturally replicate.
Voice acting is another major part of that identity. After spending hundreds of hours with these characters, I associate many of them just as strongly with their performances as I do with their designs and writing. XI S’s orchestrated soundtrack also elevates the adventure considerably, with familiar melodies gaining an appropriately grander quality that complements the enormous journey.
By contrast, those same scenes in 2D now rely primarily on sprites, text, music, and simpler animations. Conversations can move faster, and the experience more convincingly resembles an RPG from another era, but some characterization inevitably loses something without the performances and expressive animation attached to it.
Personally, I prefer the 3D version by a substantial margin. The party benefits enormously from the more expressive format, Erdrea feels grander when you can actually look across its environments, and some emotional scenes land harder when the characters are fully animated and voiced. After spending so much time with that version, I also associate these characters heavily with those performances, which made their absence particularly noticeable.
Still, calling 2D mode an inferior version of the game wouldn’t be accurate. It’s different enough that this fourth playthrough rarely felt like I was merely repeating exactly what I’d already done three times. It revealed how much of Dragon Quest XI’s identity exists independently of its modern audiovisual qualities. Its story structure, progression, combat, exploration, and sense of adventure survive translation into a format that could plausibly belong to an earlier era of the series.
Is Dragon Quest XI S Worth Playing on Switch 2?
The original Japanese 3DS version of Dragon Quest XI had its own distinct aesthetic, including a chibi-style 3D interpretation alongside the traditional 2D one. Its version of Erdrea had its own visual identity, effectively making it yet another interpretation of the same adventure.
Sadly, that version never received an official Western release, and after seeing firsthand how differently XI can feel through another format, its continued absence feels especially unfortunate. If you’re going to re-release Dragon Quest XI, bringing over a version many Western players have never had the chance to experience would give this release a much stronger reason to exist.
Playing this version again reminded me why I’ve spent roughly 400 hours with Dragon Quest XI in the first place. Its appeal is how confidently it understands why tradition still works, taking familiar RPG foundations and giving its characters and world enough time to make that familiarity feel comforting rather than creatively limiting.
More surprisingly, after three previous completions, 2D mode proved those strengths aren’t entirely dependent on the version of Dragon Quest XI I associate them with. Strip away the voice acting, expansive environments, visible encounters, and cinematic framing, and the fundamental adventure still works.
As a Switch 2 release, though, this is hard to recommend to anyone who already owns the Definitive Edition. Its improvements are modest, the lack of an upgrade path is disappointing, and the absence of the Japanese 3DS version feels like an especially unfortunate missed opportunity for another re-release of a game available on so many platforms.
Still, as Dragon Quest XI S itself, it remains one of the finest traditional RPGs of its generation. I started this fourth playthrough already knowing how highly I thought of the game, so I never expected another port to change that opinion fundamentally. What I didn’t expect was for the one mode I’d ignored for hundreds of hours to show me just how differently the same great RPG could be experienced.
Dragon Quest XI S: Echoes of an Elusive Age - Definitive Edition (Switch 2)
Dragon Quest XI S remains one of the finest traditional RPGs of its generation, with a memorable cast, patient storytelling, flexible turn-based combat, and a surprisingly transformative 2D mode. However, the Switch 2 release does little to justify another purchase for existing owners, offering only modest improvements, no upgrade path, and another missed opportunity to bring the Japanese 3DS version west.
Still, as Dragon Quest XI S itself, it remains one of the finest traditional RPGs of its generation. I started this fourth playthrough already knowing how highly I thought of the game, so I never expected another port to fundamentally change that opinion. What I didn’t expect was for the one mode I’d ignored for hundreds of hours to show me just how differently the same great RPG could be experienced.
The Good
- An Excellent Traditional RPG: Dragon Quest XI embraces classic genre foundations while delivering a remarkably expansive adventure filled with memorable characters and locations.
- A Fantastic Main Party: Extensive character development and strong interpersonal relationships make the Luminary's companions consistently compelling across the enormous journey.
- Deep, Approachable Combat: Skill panels, Pep Powers, equipment, buffs, debuffs, and party compositions provide considerable strategic flexibility without overwhelming the player.
- Transformative 2D Mode: Completely recreated environments, random encounters, and classic presentation meaningfully alter the pacing and feel of the adventure.
The Bad
- Repetitive Standard Difficulty: Regular encounters can become routine as the lengthy adventure rarely forces experienced RPG players to fully engage with its deeper mechanics.
- Underwhelming Switch 2 Upgrade: Modest improvements and no upgrade path give existing Definitive Edition owners little reason to purchase the game again.
- Missed 3DS Opportunity: The distinct Japanese 3DS version remains unavailable in the West despite being an ideal addition for another major re-release.